As the popularity and diverse nature of drones increase, the liability risks associated with drone operations increase as well. A California federal judge recently held that a standard CGL aircraft exclusion barred liability coverage for injuries related to drone operations. The case arose out of a wedding reception gone wrong when a wedding photography company operated a drone to capture the big day. While the drone was hovering at eye level, a guest collided with the drone and sustained serious injuries, including loss of sight in one eye. The court found that the drone fell under the ordinary meaning of the word “aircraft” as defined in the Merriam-Webster’s Collegiate Dictionary, even though the policy did not define the term “aircraft.” The court ruled that the insurance company could recover the costs it spent defending the wedding photographer because the exclusion meant that the insurer did not have an obligation to defend the photographer against the suit filed by the injured wedding guest.
In a previous post, we advised against relying on the ambiguity of the term “aircraft” to avoid application of the aircraft exclusion in the standard CGL policy. The ambiguity argument has become all the more dangerous as courts like this one decide that a drone is an “aircraft.”
Reliance on a CGL policy becomes more problematic because many CGL policies explicitly exclude coverage for drones. For example, Commercial General Liability Form CG 21 09 06 15 excludes coverage for an “unmanned aircraft,” which is defined as an aircraft that is not designed, built, or modified to be directly controlled by person on or in the aircraft.
CGL policies can provide liability coverage for drone operations by endorsement. Commercial General Liability Form 24 50 06 15 provides coverage for an unmanned aircraft. Coverage A provides coverage for bodily injury and property damage, while Coverage B provides coverage for personal and advertising injury. You may purchase either coverage or both.
A CGL policy does not provide property coverage for the drone or its cargo; it provides liability coverage only. Commercial Property Form 04 14 12 16 protects drones that you own, rent or lease if you have a contractual obligation to provide insurance. This endorsement is appropriate for a drone if you are not transporting cargo. If you choose to endorse your standard policy with this form, carefully describe your operation in its entirety in the schedule to procure complete coverage. Commercial Inland Marine Form IH 00 61 01 16 is a separate form that covers cargo, but its coverage is limited because it lacks business interruption coverage.
A specialty drone policy generally provides liability coverage for drone operations, as well as property coverage for the drone itself. Because specialty policies are customizable, you can select what coverage you want. Both annual policies and on-demand policies are available. On-demand policies provide time-limited coverage for specific operations, while annual policies provide coverage throughout the policy period. Insurance companies offering specialized drone policies tout their comprehensive coverage for those companies that regularly utilize drones. Both new entrants into the insurance market as well as traditional aviation insurance companies are rushing to provide this coverage, thus expanding coverage options for drone operators.
For more information on drone coverage, please view our webinar.